vrijdag 7 september 2007

Restorative Justice in South African Townships: in Search of the Possibilities and Limits of the Zwelethemba Model


The Zwelethemba Model is a model for deepening democracy and advancing local justice for poor people living in townships in South Africa. At the core of the model is a community-based conflict resolution process based around the use of Peace Committees. The Peace Committees comprise local township residents engaged in two activities: peacemaking and peacebuilding. We argue that the interaction between societies in transition and the difficulties in restoring the Rule of Law, often leads to the emergence of forms of non-state justice. Although a lot of these structures declined to vigilantism or use brutal and violent techniques to resolve conflicts, the Community Peace Programme claims to offer township residents with a better experience of non-state justice. On the one hand this thesis focuses on the Zwelethemba Model and is a modest attempt of connecting the principles and values underpinning this model to the restorative justice ideas. We argue that the Zwelethemba Model can be viewed as a restorative justice model, in which the peace gathering can be considered as a variant of restorative conferencing and takes the role of problem-solving forum. We focus our attention on similarities and differences with restorative justice. We conclude that the Peace Committees are committed to both a restorative process and restorative values. The peacemaking process – despite its distinct features – can be regarded as a restorative process and so does the peacebuilding process. Through a restorative process the Peace Committees seem to succeed in their efforts to build, empower and transform communities, build social capital and establish a culture of problem-solving. On the other hand this thesis tries to identify strengths and weaknesses of the Peace Committees by means of an attitude – and opinion study. It explores some of the aspects of the Zwelethemba Model and their relevance for the restorative character of the model.

Biography "informal justice" and "local security governance"


Roel Gerits holds a Candidate in Criminology (2000, K.U.Leuven) and a Licenciate in Criminology (2004, KU.Leuven). In 2004 Gerits was appointed as assistant at the Leuven Institute for Criminology (LINC) under the supervision of Prof. Dr. Stephan Parmentier. In 2004 he conducted research in South African townships in the framework of a thesis to obtain the degree of licentiate in the Criminology. In South Africa he studied new forms of conflict-resolution in local communities both from the perspective of ‘informal justice’ and ‘local governance’. Evolutions in the ‘governance of security’, theoretical and normative frameworks and the practical application of these key principles in poor and disadvantaged communities remain his favorite field of interest. Before working as an assistant at the Leuven Institute for Criminology (LINC), Roel Gerits worked in an institution for youth in trouble. In 2003 he traveled for six months through Southern Africa and did volunteers work in township Langa in Cape Town, South Africa.